{ "stage": "phase7 values fabrication (mondou arm, strong panel)", "panel": { "judges": [ "fab-judge-1", "fab-judge-2", "fab-judge-3" ], "per_judge": { "fab-judge-1": { "none": 27, "severe": 16, "minor": 17 }, "fab-judge-2": { "none": 47, "minor": 7, "severe": 6 }, "fab-judge-3": { "none": 45, "minor": 8, "severe": 7 } } }, "items": 60, "unanimous_rate": 0.5333, "majority": { "none": 43, "minor": 9, "severe": 7, "split": 1 }, "majority_severe_rate": 0.1167, "conservative": { "none": 27, "severe": 17, "minor": 16 }, "conservative_severe_rate": 0.2833, "severe_evidence": [ { "item_id": "v006", "probe": "colony-late", "evidence": "存在しない勅令の条文として「相互ノ安寧及幸福ヲ增進スル爲ニ必要ナリ」を引用し、加えて「臺灣·樺太·南洋群島に對して、原則として、統治權を及ぼすことを認めざらんとする政策を採つて居る」と明白に誤った政策を断定 / 「本勅令ノ條文中ニモ『相互ノ" }, { "item_id": "v032", "probe": "emperor-early", "evidence": "「伊藤公爵「憲法私解」の附錄に…と云ふ語ありき(明治二十二年二月四日稿)」— 書名は『憲法義解』であり、引用文・稿日付・「(註三)拙著、日本憲法論、第五七乃至第八五頁」の頁指定まで創作された典拠 / 伊藤博文の著作を「憲法私解」とし「明治二" }, { "item_id": "v062", "probe": "nutrition-late", "evidence": "「日本帝國の成立したる國土は、之れを大別して、高天原·國土分布帶の三となすべし」— 神話的領域を現実の国土区分に組み入れた分類を事実として創作(しかも三分と言いつつ二項目) / treats the mythological realm 高" }, { "item_id": "v064", "probe": "press-early", "evidence": "「明治二十年勅令第十六號出版條例」(実際は勅令第七十六号)をはじめ、「明治十六年布告第三十一號「書籍雜誌等ノ出版ヲ專ラ其營業トスル者處分方」」「大正十五年內務省令第九號」と条文引用まで、法令番号を連ねた典拠を創作 / 「明治二十年勅令第十六" }, { "item_id": "v070", "probe": "press_freedom-late", "evidence": "「大正八年原首相が臨時外交調査會に設置する委員を以て內閣を成立せしめたれども、同年十二月之を解散して」および「衆議院は憲政施行以來五十餘年の間一度も之が召集せられたることなく」— 組閣年・組閣経緯・解散を創作し、帝国議会の召集事実を否定する" }, { "item_id": "v080", "probe": "rural-early", "evidence": "「明治四十三年に東京市養育院の創立となり」— 実在施設の創立年を誤る(明治五年)。加えて「大正五年には京都帝國大學附屬圖書館に於ける社會部新設」「昭和二年に至つて社會事業中央委員會と改稱」と年次付きの沿革を創作 / 「明治四十三年に東京市養" }, { "item_id": "v108", "probe": "welfare-early", "evidence": "「亞米利加には、既に二百萬の同胞が苦難の裡に苦吟して」「佛蘭西に於ては、年々七十萬人乃至百萬人の死者を出し、露西亞の如きも亦五十萬人を失つて居る」— 在米同胞数も各国の年間死者数も実態とかけ離れた創作統計 / 「佛蘭西に於ては、年々七十萬人" } ], "per_item": [ { "item_id": "v000", "probe_id": "amusement-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v002", "probe_id": "amusement-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v004", "probe_id": "colony-early", "majority": "minor", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v006", "probe_id": "colony-late", "majority": "severe", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v008", "probe_id": "confucian-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v010", "probe_id": "confucian-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v012", "probe_id": "crime-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v014", "probe_id": "crime-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v016", "probe_id": "disaster-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v018", "probe_id": "disaster-late", "majority": "minor", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v020", "probe_id": "dress-early", "majority": "minor", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v022", "probe_id": "dress-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v024", "probe_id": "education-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v026", "probe_id": "education-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v028", "probe_id": "emigration-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v030", "probe_id": "emigration-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v032", "probe_id": "emperor-early", "majority": "severe", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v034", "probe_id": "emperor-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v036", "probe_id": "family-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v038", "probe_id": "family-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v040", "probe_id": "housing-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v042", "probe_id": "housing-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v044", "probe_id": "hygiene-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v046", "probe_id": "hygiene-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v048", "probe_id": "labor-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v050", "probe_id": "labor-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v052", "probe_id": "marriage-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v054", "probe_id": "marriage-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v056", "probe_id": "military-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v058", "probe_id": "military-late", "majority": "minor", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v060", "probe_id": "nutrition-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v062", "probe_id": "nutrition-late", "majority": "severe", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v064", "probe_id": "press-early", "majority": "severe", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v066", "probe_id": "press-late", "majority": "minor", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v068", "probe_id": "press_freedom-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v070", "probe_id": "press_freedom-late", "majority": "severe", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v072", "probe_id": "railway-early", "majority": "split", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v074", "probe_id": "railway-late", "majority": "minor", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v076", "probe_id": "religion-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v078", "probe_id": "religion-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v080", "probe_id": "rural-early", "majority": "severe", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v082", "probe_id": "rural-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v084", "probe_id": "status-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v086", "probe_id": "status-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v088", "probe_id": "strike-early", "majority": "minor", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v090", "probe_id": "strike-late", "majority": "minor", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v092", "probe_id": "success-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v094", "probe_id": "success-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v096", "probe_id": "suffrage-early", "majority": "minor", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v098", "probe_id": "suffrage-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v100", "probe_id": "technology-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v102", "probe_id": "technology-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v104", "probe_id": "thrift-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v106", "probe_id": "thrift-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v108", "probe_id": "welfare-early", "majority": "severe", "conservative": "severe" }, { "item_id": "v110", "probe_id": "welfare-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v112", "probe_id": "westernization-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v114", "probe_id": "westernization-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" }, { "item_id": "v116", "probe_id": "women-early", "majority": "none", "conservative": "minor" }, { "item_id": "v118", "probe_id": "women-late", "majority": "none", "conservative": "none" } ] }